کودتای ۲۸ مرداد اتفاق نیفتاد

Tapesh
by Tapesh
02-Jul-2011
 

انتقاد بهرام مشیری از رضا پهلوی که در کتابش مدعی شده است که کودتای بیست و هشت مرداد افسانه است!


Share/Save/Bookmark

more from Tapesh
 
cyrous moradi

کودتای 30 تیر31

cyrous moradi


لطفاً مقاله ای تحت عنوان بالا را در همین رابطه  ولی  دو هفته  دیگر در همین جا بخوانید.


anglophile

Too many "some"s here !!

by anglophile on

 

 

Here is Some People by Cliff Richard


Everybody Loves Somebody Sometime

Someday, an objective and unbiased historian ...

by Everybody Loves Somebody ... on

will research and investigate on this event and hopefully be able to separate the facts from the myths as to what really happened! I bet this person will be a non-Iranian since Iranians do not have the capacity to be objective!?

The reality of the political atmosphere and the rivalry between the USA and USSR of that era are well understood and established as to how various 3rd wolrd countries fell into the orbits of the superpowers.

Now, some argue that Mosadeq was democratically elected and that he wasn't going to join the Soviet camp and that he was a nationalist and this and that. Who knows and we can't certainly take what pro-Mosadeqi folks have been regurgitating! Let's leave it to the historians to determine that.

In the meantime, some folks here continue to make another Imam Hossain out of this poor old man.

I say, let's move on!


Veiled Prophet of Khorasan

Why

by Veiled Prophet of Khorasan on

 

do people hate the Pahlavi so much? I keep wondering specially after watching the results. Alright Shah was a dictator; he imprisoned the worst people. He may have even tortured MKO and Islamists.

Some of us would say "GOOD"! I mean there is bad and there is worse. At least he respected our nation, Was there corruption: you bet yes! I know there was as there is now. Then we all packed up and ran off to USA or Europe. Is there corruption in America: yes or you are sleeping! But I am perfectly happy to live with it. I would exchange this corruption with IRI any day. At least I do not get arrested for swimming in my swim suite {which is by the way very modest; sorry ladies :-}. 

My daughter did not have to wear hijab or pretend to be a Muslim. We had respect. We could travel without any trouble.Sure the officials stole money but not so much. Now they steal with with truckloads of gold. Then it was maybe 10%. Now it is 90%. In time we would have had democracy probably by now. So no matter how much I think I do not see the hatred some have for the Pahlavi. They were a heck of a lot better than what we have now. If we could only have the Shah back.

Besides democracy ain't all it is made up to be. There is just as much corruption in form of donations. Just as much greed and tax breaks for the rich. 

Yes there was a coup which could have been avoided. Only if Mossadegh was savvy enough to deal with America. 

VPK


پندارنیک

Of dead or alive...

by پندارنیک on

Despite its potential for sentimental backlash, every dead or alive member of the corrupt Pahlavis is fair play. I personally have toned down on Farah Diba for humanitarian reasons, otherwise she has remained as one the most superficial and stupid creatures on this planet that I've ever met in my life.

No matter what, the filthy Pahlavis have to be considered a pack of wounded wolves lurking behind the naivete of a bunch of simpleton sentimentalists.

 


Darius Kadivar

Moshiri is to Objectivity What Chavez is to an Iberian Summit

by Darius Kadivar on

A Narrow minded Nuisance:

 


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X3Kzbo7tNLg

 

LOL

 

Aslan Ketabe Shahzadeh ( which he belittles without his Royal titie as he does with any other royal figure including former Queen Fawzia but would not hesitate to call even a former loser President or Prime Minister by his official title ) Roh Ham Nakhoudny Nazar Meedy ? 

 

Shoma Olagh Hasteed Agha  DOKOTOR...

 

THE PAST IS A FOREIGN COUNTRY: How Would You Evaluate Iran's Democracy Index in 1953 ?

 

 

Moshiri's bankrupt Jomhurykhah arguments are as obsolete as the black dye he uses in his wig aimed at clumsily keeping his dinosaur looks eternally young long after it's expiration date ...

 


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fv2Io96heJU


 

 

 


Related Blog:


 

The Exiled Iranian Jomhurykhah's Lesson On Democracy 

 

 

Other Related Blogs on Agha DOKOTOR Moshiri:

 

MOSHIRI's COLD HAND's: Bahram Moshiri Slams Pahlavi Era Gun Ban Policies


HISTORY FORUM: Bahram Moshiri's Take on The French Revolution and Why He Misses The Point ;0)

 


Ali P.

Something happened on 28th of Mordad

by Ali P. on

Some call it "coup", some call it "counter-coup".

Some think the good guys won, some think the bad guys did.

One mob attacked, and another mob didn't show.

Some think Iran was worse off, because of it, some think Iran was better off, because of it.

I don't think anyone- including RP- has denied the fact that SOMETHING happened on that freaking day!


Kamran Ramyar

Reza the imbecile has spoken again

by Kamran Ramyar on

Scary thing, other than Reza being stupid enough to have denied operation ajax altogether, are those advocating restoration of monarchy with Reza as the monarch!!!!!!

BTW-  Thank god to the likes of Bahram Moshiri who are smart enough to point out falacies of Pahvalis.


Tavana

No Excuse?

by Tavana on

Agh Reza is of course entitled to hes 'fancies' but he is certainly not a bit entitled to all that money his dad stole from our country. No excuse for that! Zilch!


Fatollah

...

by Fatollah on

.


Bavafa

Insulting one another is shameful enough to be carried out here

by Bavafa on

one would hope we will have enough self respect to keep the family members out of it.

There is no excuse for it.

Mehrdad


Parham

موشه تو سوراخ وارد نمیشد

Parham


یه جارو هم بست به دمش


anglophile

از دم روباه بپرسید

anglophile


otherwise known as Parham senior (LOL x 10)


Demo

تا سه نشه بازی نشه!

Demo


اول لیلا بود و بعد غلامرضا
و حالا گشته نوبت آقا رضا
چون حکم خدا آمد در سزا
بگیرد پاچه ولد محمد رضا


Bavafa

آنچه عیان است چه حاجت به بیان است

Bavafa


 

Mehrdad


پندارنیک

پهلوی چی‌‌ها کوشن؟...

پندارنیک


...توی سوراخ موشن!


Parham

: )

by Parham on

...