نظر شما چیست؟ مناسب ترین نظام برای ایران کدام است؟

aynak
by aynak
27-Aug-2010
 

لطفا فقط یکی را انتخاب کرده (تصور بفرمایید چنین رفراندمی امروز برقرارشده ) -  چون امکان رای گیری مخفی متاسفانه موجود نیست، لطفا در  بدنه بانوشتن نمره انتخاب رای دهید،  پس از ۷ روز (شنبه آینده) نتیجه را ثبتمیکنیم و پس از ان رای گیری خاتمه پیدا می کند.  

۱-حکومت "جمهوری   اسلامی" (به گونه فعلی، از بدو آن تا کنون)
۲ -حکومت اسلامی (همان بالایی بدون انتخابات+ ولایت مطلقه فقیه ) 

  ۳- نظری ندارم 

۴-جمهوری اسلامی (همان بالایی بدون ولی فقیه،جموهری اسلامی  پاکستان )
۵-حکومت سلطنتی (مانند زمان شاه، پادشاهی عربستان )
۶ -دولت سلطنتی مشروطه(پارلمانی با شاه)  (انگلیس ، سوئد،اسپانیا  ...)
۷ -دولت پارلمانی (جمهوری/نخست وزیر ) کلیه مقامات تصمیم گیرنده انتخابیهستند.( جمهوری فرانسه ، جمهوری فدرال آلمان ،جمهوری  هند،  آمریکا   ....)
۸ -حکومت  کمونیستی (تصمیم گیری توسط حزب واحد ، مانند چین )
۹-حکومت جمهوری با پسوند (جمهوری دمکراتیک خلق کره، جمهوری عربی  مصر، جمهوری عربی سوریه)


Share/Save/Bookmark

more from aynak
 
aynak

Sorry Shazdeh, missed it, here's an update

by aynak on

 

and the list is frozen as promised.  (that will put the option seven at slightly higher than 70% here).

2 people voted for  option 6 (constitutional monarchy)

1 person voted for Islamic Republic 9

17 people voted option 7 (Jomhoury, fully elected system)

2 people voted for option 3 (however they like to take it).


Shazde Asdola Mirza

Conclusion: I make my own - you say?

by Shazde Asdola Mirza on

Well I conclude that my vote does not count ... again!

Dear Aynak: what happened to my vote for the 7 th option, right underneath you nose?

Now I have to start a green movement to get my vote count?


aynak

Final tally and an analysis

by aynak on

2 people voted for  option 6 (constitutional monarchy)

1 person voted for Islamic Republic 9

16 people voted option 7 (Jomhoury, fully elected system)

2 people voted for option 3 (however they like to take it).

===================================================

This obviously is not a scientific poll.    However, in the context of a poll taken from a specific group, it has certain telling property.

Of those who voted, and this has been hanging here for anyone to participate, we see an overwhelming support for a option 7, or a system of government that is based on frequent/free/open voting system to decide who should run a future Iran.  In including the 2 incomprehnsible votes:

out of 23, 16 voted for this.

70% For a fully elected government (Republic, or a Prime-minister based head of government etc, which comes to power strictly on direct or indirect vote).

roughly 9% (8.65%) pr 2 votes were cast for a constitutional monarchy

same for no option.

and 4.5% (1 voted) for some sort of Islamic government.

=====================================================

Observations:

1-Some bloggers who show up supporting Isalmic Regimes government with 100 different user names, did not find the concept of a poll very appealing.  Makes you wonder why?

2-Some bloggers who presumably want their version of democracy but  belive in bombing Iran to democracy (much like it has been achieved in Afghanestan and Iraq already), are conspicuously absent here as well.

3-People who  fundamentally don't  believe in voting as the ultimate tie break in political disputes, but advocate it for short term gains, typically make fun of any attempt to do so, and they are obvious in this thread as well.

4-I have conducted, and have seen similar polls conducted in various internet media outlets.  Without exception  option 7 gains the majority.   However, when we look at the Persian speaking TV's or listen to Radios, it appears they are almost exclusively controlled by supporters of IRI or Monarchy.   This results in general mis perception,  suggestiong these two options (Islamic governments/Monarchy) with much less popular support are the only viable choices.

Conclusion:

You make your own.

 


Shazde Asdola Mirza

Hey, this is getting serious - I want a number 7 too!

by Shazde Asdola Mirza on

Hope it isn't too late ;-)


aynak

tally by the end of day 5

by aynak on

2 people voted for  option 6 (constitutional monarchy)

1 person voted for Islamic Republic 9

16 people voted option 7 (Jomhoury, fully elected system)

2 people voted for option 3 (however they like to take it).

====

2 votes dismissed because I can not comprehend them.  A 7.5 and one by MS.Roosta who just dislikes Mossadegh.

Thank you all for participating and all the comments, and will close this on Saturday.

 

 


Red Wine

...

by Red Wine on

Number 7 please ,Thank you .


MM

news flash - voting doen't change via stuffing comments here

by MM on

71 comments, but only 21 votes!

Good job Aynak.


David ET

My vote is :

by David ET on

7


Farah Rusta

Wrong tally again!

by Farah Rusta on

There is no voting pro or against Mossadegh's style of government. This option was offered to complete an otherwise incomplete list.  

FR


aynak

No change by the end of 4th day

by aynak on

those who know they can not win a popular vote --on an ongoing basis--  for the reactionary systesm they propose, would try to be cute with their responses.
Otherwise, the numbers I have seen here as well as other sites with bigger samples, tells a clear desire, for a fully electable and accountable system of government.   That is why, supporters of these dictatorships, (Just like Islamic Regime) would not mind a --One time-- referendom.   But it is the permanance of voting as a tool that is so frightening to them.   After all, it is easy to be a democrat while you are not in power.   Even Khomanee proved that while in Paris.   In Tehran though....

=======================

2 people voted for  option 6 (constitutional monarchy)

1 person voted for Islamic Republic 9

14 people voted option 7 (Jomhoury, fully elected system)

2 people voted for option 3 (however they like to take it).

1 Person voted against Mossadegh


Farah Rusta

Wrong tally again!

by Farah Rusta on

There is no voting pro or against Mossadegh's style of government. This option was offered to complete an otherwise incomplete list.

 

Khar Magas Jaan

 

Thank you  for your kind reference to this za'eefeh (using wprds Majid would understand better). You may call yourself marhoum, but thankfully you are well and truly alive. 

Best,

FR


aynak

end of 3rd day tally

by aynak on

 

3 more for 7.   Sorry, can not round up fractions and other non-direct responses.

=======================

2 people voted for  option 6 (constitutional monarchy)

1 person voted for Islamic Republic 9

14 people voted option 7 (Jomhoury, fully elected system)

2 people voted for option 3 (however they like to take it).

1 Person voted against Mossadegh


default

LOL

by Doctor X on

Writing when you are mad, is like making love when you watch Nightline or This week On ABC. It is no fun.

Call Dr. Ghhooot (ruth) she will help you find out what is wrong with... or rather within you.


marhoum Kharmagas

Don't stir it more Doctor X!

by marhoum Kharmagas on

As I said I could care less that you have multiple IDs (KouroshS, Sheeshaki, aghay MobseL (the kid below)..... BUT that is until you start doing your attacks..... then I make fun of you (and enjoy it too), so Calm down kid, don't stir what you are in.


benross

A quote from Nike530

by benross on


"Hope to be better. Better means more features.

----------------

nike air | nike shoes | nike air max | air max 2011"

As relevant as any! 


default

Hey . Hey.

by Doctor X on

Calm down there little buddy.

Can you not find anything else to obsess over?

The Trick is ...

So spoke the Mighty Alexander. LOL.

I think IC should add a Mental/psychiatric ward here. Some people really need it. Watch out...


marhoum Kharmagas

Pirates Election! [ to Doctor X (where X=....)]

by marhoum Kharmagas on

Doctor X says: "Majid : hemayatat mikonim"

 

Doctor X, nagholaa  is aghay mobseL(forgive my bisavaati) your other ID in addition to Sheeshaki, KouroshS, Shamsheer, ....the similarity between you "two" is astonishing! You "TWO" will win in Pirates Election:

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=9EnOjGuQkNs&feature...

The punchline is 

"the trick is living with yourself" Kouroshi!, I could care less that you have multiple IDs.

 


default

Majid : hemayatat mikonim

by Doctor X on

Damet har chi adame chiz fahmeh garm bekhoda.

Bezan berrfess bache tanbalaro aghabe kelass. Ba ye dare folani:))

ta dige havaseshoon jam basheh ba magasa ghati nashan.


Majid

من «مُبصل» که نیستم هیچ حتی «مبصر» هم نیستم!

Majid


 

من مثل اینکه باید  معلّم کلاس اوّل بشم اینجا! خدایا مردم از بس فارسی نوشتن بعضی ها رو تصحیح کردم!

واجب بود اون بلا رو سر خودت بیاری که حالا مجبور بشی کامنت هات رو با اسم «خرمگس مرده» بنویسی؟


marhoum Kharmagas

thank you agha majid!

by marhoum Kharmagas on

Jenaabe mobsel kellas, I am glad you have found my vezvez annoying to your goushe mobarak. 


yousef

Mr/Mrs "no fear"

by yousef on

All you have to do is to cast your vote, then leave and allow others to do the same. This is called "DEMOCRACY"!

I know you have to earn a living like the rest of us, but nobody asked you for your long essays and I doubt many if any gonna read them either!

 


Majid

مرحوم وزوز العلماء، شهید شده توسط مگس کش:

Majid


 


یه نصیحت از این «کید» به شما که حتی در زمان حیات هم  وزوزتون(نظرتون) غیر از مزاحمت چیزی نبود چه برسه به حالا که مرحوم هم شدین!

شما کیک تون (یا نوع اصفهانی ش رو) رو بخورین، ساندیس میل دارین؟


default

Sorry Mr. Aynak

by Doctor X on

No fear

Once again, Under the guise of "this is the nature of the system" You have presented the most Irrelevant and Totally unrelated evidence to prove your case. Whatever that maybe! Non of these are convincing, You know that and we know that too. You have gone over these a Zillion times and judging by the way things are going, we have not heard the end of it:))

It is like when someone demolishes your modern home that you have worked hard on all your life to build and builds you a house of out of cardboard and straws and then turns around and says. Bia. Boro khoda ro shokr kon Ke badtar az in geeret nayoomad!!


default

Majid jan

by Doctor X on

Al hagho Val ensaf Ke gol gofti.

Kheili bahal gofti


Anonymouse

Seven.............. I agree with Majid what's all the haggling?

by Anonymouse on

Everything is sacred


marhoum Kharmagas

I go for 7.5 Majid Agha!

by marhoum Kharmagas on

Shoumaa, va Frau Blukher arameshedonaa hefz koonid! Some of us like this hagheer (and perhaps Khanome Rusta) don't know math.

BTW, despite our differences I like to read Rusta's (specially her's), No Fear's, Ari's , and even Daijaan Comrad's views ...... and what they have here is more related to the toppic than your comment! Some of us like the cake more than the frosting, kids like you ... may like the frosting more, and I am sure Aynak does not mind higher hits on his/her article!


Farah Rusta

How true No Fear, how true!

by Farah Rusta on

"Realpolitik ( political realism ) is not something you can find on an IC forum. ;)  
"

 BTW, wouldn't you say that your very presence on this site is a testimony to the above claim? 

Just asking.

 

FR


No Fear

Ari,

by No Fear on

I suspect Ahmadinejad has lost the support of the ultra conservatives and the traditional conservatives in Iran. But i hope he has gained more from the secular greens to his credit.

Its hard to estimate how much support he has lost and how much he has gained. But i think when his subsidy elimination policy comes in full effect, he would lose even more support.


Ari Siletz

Thanks no fear

by Ari Siletz on

"...best transitional candidate to bridge between IR version 1.0 and the next step forward."

What is the next step forward? Also--in your estimate--how many Iranians who voted for Ahmadinejad support those goals and how many prefer IR version 1.0?


No Fear

Ari, ( about civil rights )

by No Fear on

While Ahmadinejad is in no way representing an ideal system, he is the best transitional candidate to bridge between IR version 1.0 and the next step forward. We voted for him not because he was our goal, but because he could remove certain obstacles and make reaching our goals, easier. We also never doubted his nationalistic credentials.

I understand as a diasporan you are interested about foreign policies and civil rights. Ahmadinejad has had profound influences on both these issues.

For the first time in IR history, a woman was appointed as a minister in Ahmadinejad's cabinet. This was interesting since Ahmadinejad purged the clergies from the administration. He also allowed women to attend a football match which caused quite a controversy. While he gave in to the pressure, he pushed forward for a women's football team and won this battle.
Ahmadinejad also delayed the " monkeraat bill " introduction to the parliament for ratification for 6 years. This also caused quite a controversy which resulted in a split between the neo conservatives and the traditional conservatives headed by Larijani. Ask any family in Iran and they will tell you the freedom of dressing and the relaxation on it is unprecedented in IR history in Iran. Women could only wear Purple, brown or black dresses before Ahmadinejad era on the streets. Take a look at Iran now!  Ahmadinejad has always mentioned how people dress is not his administration objectives.

Also, freedom of expression improved greatly during his administration. As a person who goes through most of Iranian publications in Iran ( Daily News ), I can testify that there are more newspapers opposing his administration than those who are pro Ahmadinejad. Iranians also enjoy relative freedom over the internet. Blogs and social network sites are a huge thing in Iran. Many of these freedoms were banned during the most liberal reformist president in Iran. Just as an example, in the recent book exhibition in Iran, we noticed Ayatollah Shariatmadari's book on the shelves! This was after a 30 year ban on his books. Do you understand how huge this is?

Do i need to mention the benefits of public debates which Ahmadinejad started?

Have you seen the recent musics coming out of Iran?  I saw one and i thought it was recorded in Los Angeles, seriously. Women were singing and playing musical instruments. Ofcourse these are basic rights, but even your beloved reformists denied our people from these basic rights.

But perhaps the one that i care the most is the handling of political prisoners. While Ahmadinejad's admin. is not entirely influential on the fate of these prisoners, but he has constantly mentioned that his government works closely with the judiciary and keep asking for leniency. I compare some of these sentences with those who were convicted before Ahmadinejad's era, and there is a noticable difference in the severity of sentences.
Heck, i am just glad the prisoners names are publicly published and their voices heard.

Show me any other politician in Iran's recent history who has done more?