Press TV under investigation

UK regulators concerned by lack of impartiality

14-Nov-2009
Share/Save/Bookmark

Recently by Ghormeh SabziCommentsDate
Majid Tavakoli: Prisoner of the day
5
Dec 02, 2012
Nasrin Sotoudeh: Prisoner of the day
2
Dec 01, 2012
Abdollah Momeni: Prisoner of the day
2
Nov 30, 2012
more from Ghormeh Sabzi
 
Freedom5

American Dream = Islamic Republic Agent

by Freedom5 on

  See American Dream comment about the people up-rising in IRAN    These protests are just plain bogus

by American Dream on

These protests are just plain bogus.  The protests won't change anything.  All the protests will do is damage people's cars.

 


American Dream

Darius Kadivar

by American Dream on

"1) The German Law does not apply to other countries. It is specific to the history of Germany and it's responsability in the Holocaust and WWII."

Why are Germans being punished and their freedom of speech being violated for something that happened more than 64 years ago?

2) I don't see why a Democratic society should tolerate the presence of a TV like Sahar or Press TV on their soil when that country ( Iran) does not respect Journalistic ethics and more importantly refuses foreign journalists to work on their soil. If that was the case then I suppose at the Hight of the Cold War America should have allowed the Soviets to propagate their propaganda when they had invaded Afghanistan.

Two wrongs don't make a right.  Freedom of speech and expression are a must in all democracies.

Press TV wishes to boast itself as the IRanian equivalent of Al Jazeera. Well Press TV is NO Al Jazeera neither in terms of quality, objectivity or Journalistic Ethics.

Why would Press TV want to be like Al Jazeera?  Al Jazeera calls the Persian Gulf the "Arabian Gulf".  Al Jazeera is absurd to say the least.


Darius Kadivar

American Dream

by Darius Kadivar on

1) The German Law does not apply to other countries. It is specific to the history of Germany and it's responsability in the Holocaust and WWII.

It is not meant to be  democratic decision on behalf of the German goverment ( which is by all accounts Democratic) but Germany's own way of seeing itself accountable for it's past and make sure that no German will ever be responsible for the ressurgence of the Nazi Ideology again in the history of mankind. Call it undemocratic or Utopian, I think that given that Hitler was elected democratically, the justification behing this law is a moral standpoint by the German people at large who want to dissociate themselves with that dangerous ideology. 

West German Chancellor Willy Brandt Kneeling in Warsaw during a State Visit in 1970's in front of  Monument dedicated to the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. and the victims of the Holocaust to Beg forgiveness in the name of the German People.

 //www.youtube.com/watch?v=rp4jq7Ojb7E

2) I don't see why a Democratic society should tolerate the presence of a TV like Sahar or Press TV on their soil when that country ( Iran) does not respect Journalistic ethics and more importantly refuses foreign journalists to work on their soil. If that was the case then I suppose at the Hight of the Cold War America should have allowed the Soviets to propagate their propaganda when they had invaded Afghanistan.

It is the Moral Responsability of Democratic countries to stand for the People who struggle for Democracy as was the case let's say for Poland during the Solidarnosc mouvement or during WWII when America and the West stood against the Nazi's and stopped them to propagate their propoganda in the West.

Iran should Not be an Exception to the Rule.

Press TV wishes to boast itself as the IRanian equivalent of Al Jazeera. Well Press TV is NO Al Jazeera neither in terms of quality, objectivity or Journalistic Ethics.

Best,

DK

 


American Dream

Darius Kadivar, I was writing about the west

by American Dream on

I was writing about freedom of speech and expression in the west.

The topic was about Press TV in the U.K.

"As for Michelle Renouf she a well known Australian socialite of Austrian Origine "

Really?  I have never heard of Michelle Renouf. 

"France's Far Right  Jean Marie LE PEN"

I didn't know who is this guy.  He must be big news in France.  Thank you for posting that informational clip about Mr. Le Pen. 

I don't agree with Ms. Rebouf.  I don't agree with Mr. Le Pen.  That being said, with freedom of speech and expression in the west they should be able to say what they think.  Why should they be fined or put in jail for their speech or expression.  If they are fined or put in jail in what way is their situation any different from Mr. Bahari?  Any censorship of freedom of speech and expression in the west is wrong. 


Darius Kadivar

American Dream Oh Yeah ? I wonder if Maziar Bahari agrees ;0)

by Darius Kadivar on

Then Why are Reformist Journalists jailed in IRan, Newspapers closed down and the internet filtered in IRan as well as any foreign media from VOA to Radio Farda.

journalists arrested in IRan:

//www.rsf.org/Repressive-mania-continues-three.html

"A crackdown against journalists and cyber-dissidents is continuing in Iran with both Iranian and foreign journalists caught in the eye of the post-election storm, Reporters Without Borders said. Among the latest arrests was that of a correspondent for the US magazine Newsweek, Maziar Bahari, picked up at his home in Tehran on 21 June.

“The authorities are using all possible methods to drive foreign journalists out of Iran, where they are unwanted witnesses to bloody repression,” the worldwide press freedom organisation said. “The arrest of the Newsweekcorrespondent is a clear sign of the regime’s determination to intimidate journalists whether Iranian or foreign, local or international newspaper correspondents.”

The latest arrests bring the number of journalists picked up and imprisoned since the disputed presidential election to 26."

As for Michelle Renouf she a well known Australian socialite of Austrian Origine (Just like Hitler who was not German but Austrian ) and a NEO NAZI and Holocaust Revisionist whose comments in Germany would lead to being Fined or worst imprisonement given Germany's responsability in the Holocaust.  

If Some marginal Iranians  may not be as senstitive to the Holocaust Denial debate it may be because they only lost 200 people due to the WWII Conflict that cost the lives of 70 Million men, women and Children amongst which 6 Million Jews were EXTERMINATED by the Nazis. I suppose IN YOUR BOOK That was a DEtail in the history of WWII . In that I am sure you would be in good company with France's Far Right  Jean Marie LE PEN :

France's Le Pen insists Nazi death camps were 'detail' :

 //www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hqg6M_R-ME0


American Dream

Darius Kadivar, it all boils down to freedom of speech

by American Dream on

It all boils down to freedom of speech.  Press TV and Sahar TV should also be given the right to freedom of speech and expression. 

The clip you posted wrote that Michelle Renouf was austrian.  Austrians speak and write German.  The name Michelle Renouf does not appear to be German.  The name looks French.

 


ramintork

IRI strategy for dealing with facts and the media

by ramintork on

Q: What is this big elephant doing in this room?

A: What elephant?

Q: The one that we can all see?

A: What, you think that it is unusual to find elephants in people's rooms? In Israel and US everyone has an elephant in their room.

Q: That is debatable, besides your elephant is suffocating the people in the room.

A: This is an elephant which was brought in by the foreign conspirators, and the Zionist.

Q: But it is your elephant, it has your name on it!

A: I can only speak for the room itself and not the elephant. Is it my fault that you did not do your research in who owns this animal?

Q: But you own the elephant.

A: It is your shortcoming if you find me in this room and although I am in charge of rooms and allegedly you find my name on the elephant you have come up with the misconception that I have anything to do with an elephant which you claim is mine. Besides this is not an elephant it is a horse, an Islamic horse! We consider it as part of our national right to keep our Islamic horses in our rooms!

 


Darius Kadivar

You can't compare FOX News and Press TV because

by Darius Kadivar on

Nor is there ANY possible parrallel between the American Media's pluralism and Iran's heavily censored and one sided Media.

For every Conservative Media in the US, you will find a Liberal Media to compensate for their views.

Also America and Western Medias work within a Free Society where the government is not a dictatorship like in Iran. Every News media will have it's contradictors and will remain accountable if it distorts the truth be it by the readers and society in general. You can't just speak crap without expecting some backfire at some point. 

Otherwise How could Obama ever have even been elected if all news in America was boiled down to FOX news version of social and political views in America ? 

This Oversimplification of the West and it's medias in the eyes of IRI apologists but also in general by most Third World dictatorial Medias who try to present themselves as equal in professionalism and objectivity is truly a pathetic attempt to divert people from the real issue: The Freedom of PRess in their own country which is inexistent.

How can Press TV claim to any objectivity to anything when nearly all Reformist Newspapers are shut down and no other authorized media in IRan can have their say or contradict them ?

They are not the only State Sponsored Media in IRan. Another one is SAHAR TV which has made its reputation on hosting Revisionist historical debates on the Holocaust and inviting NEO NAZI revisionists like Michelle Renouf which they present like a Human Rights Activist.

HOLOCAUST A MYTH: Michelle Renouf on Iranian SAHAR TV

This is PATHETIC !

With all their shortcomings the Western PRess IS PLURALISTIC where as PRESS TV and other IRANIAN STATE SPONSORED Medias are NOT !

 


jondoe5000

if you think PTV is legit, i've got prime swamp land to sell ya!

by jondoe5000 on


All news agencies have an agenda.  This is not a secret.  Fox News is conservative, MSNBC is leftist, etc, etc....but at least they REPORT HISTORIC EVENTS, even if they do insert their own agenda. The thing with PressTV is that they completely and unabashedly turn a blind eye to historic events that occur in their own country.  Here's a great example for you.  Remember the silent march in Tehran, 17 June 2009?  Millions of people were there.  Does this not constitute a historic event?  Mind you, not since the 1979 Revolution has such an assembly come together in a public venue. THE SILENT MARCH WAS A HISTORIC EVENT.  They are big fat zeros when it comes to legitimacy.  And, anyone who works for PressTV should not call themselves journalists.  They should call themselves stooges, esp. those Brits and Americans.  How can they live with themselves?  They are total sellouts.  Have they no shame?  Is the money really that good?  


Bavafa

I think HHH has got this right on the money

by Bavafa on

Mehrdad


Faramarz_Fateh

HHH, u must have been absent when

by Faramarz_Fateh on

HHH, u must have been absent when brains was being distributed.

BBC=British Nazi prozionist ?!!!!

Do you realize how utterly moronic is this statement?


Benyamin

In fairness

by Benyamin on

Unlike the Uk iran`s wealth in its entierity(history,culture,religion money and so on) has been taken by Khameneie`s unroyal circle of leadership at any cost and therefore the current iranian leadership acts as if they "own" Iran and everything within it! that is why no one in Iran can say anything about the media in Iran but any one decides to do so then they are only allowed to talk once because the regime wont give the second chance. We can call it Honey Bee policy.

where as in the UK the country is owned by everyone and the royal family is just symbolizing the country. I am glad that PressTV is being PRESSED for what they have been reporting.

 

 


HHH

They're All Bought & Paid For

by HHH on

PRESS TV = IRI

FOX NEWS = Rupert Murdoch, Neo-Cons, Zionists, Nazis

MSNBC = Far Left Democrats

CNN = Zionist international (wolf Blitzer)+ Left national

BBC = British Nazi conservative agenda, pro-zionist

AlJazira = Sunni Arab, British agenda

Just like the "Hollybooks" they each mix some good, neutral words with their own agenda to make their words seem fair & neutral.

People are not stupid and illiterate anymore. At least not all. People see behind their words and catch what's missing from their news, people catch the lies and exaggerations. 

 


Darius Kadivar

FYI/ More Press TV Junk with Kaveh Afrasiabi & Mohammad Marandi

by Darius Kadivar on

Dr Ali Ansari ( leading Expert on IRanian history and associate fellow, Chatham House) slams experts Mohammad Marandi and Kaveh Afrasiabi two well known IRI Apologists on PressTV on Iran post Election Uprising /Election Fraud:

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=c3ZEiVZptvw&feature=related

 

To watch entire show

Part I:

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=awuQ0w_mAqw&feature=related

Part II

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=YumzgjD-cXM&feature=related

Part III

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=fPjByKtyuik&feature=related

 

PS: Mohammad Marandi making a fool of himself on Fareed Zakaria (CNN 2009)

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTTMQ0yO0Es

 


Darius Kadivar

Where isHamid Dabashi to defend his Friend George Galloway ? ;0)

by Darius Kadivar on

Hamid Dabashi Where Art Thou ?

//iranian.com/main/2009/nov/hamid-dabashi

George Galloway Comments Iran's Presidential Election - Part 1 of 7

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=qL3yhzV2wWU

Hamid Dabashi and George Galloway on the Gaza Crisis :

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=qbdohw4o02E


Darius Kadivar

Who You Gonna Call ? ;0)

by Darius Kadivar on

What do you do When you meet Resident Aliens ? 

You Call the Ghostbusters !

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=g4uxIo4t7xM&feature=related

DOWN WITH THE IRI !

LOL

 


yolanda

......

by yolanda on

I visit Press TV website at least once a day. (Of course I visit IC way more often than that.....:O)) I like to see the sports news, soccer news, etc on PressTV website.....I did learn something there.....I read about Persian turquoise mine in Iran and also this beautiful cave discovered by British spelunkers in 1976....it is just gorgeous, it is full of stalactites and stalagmites....

//www.presstv.com/detail.aspx?id=71455

//www.presstv.com/detail.aspx?id=79022

I read a bizarre article on Press TV website, the article said that soybean can cause infertility among men. The reality is that China is the biggest soybean (tofu is made of soybean) consumer in the world, and also is the most populous country on planet Earth with 1.2 billion people. China forces their citizens not to have more than one child. It looks like soybean products make people too fertile instead of infertile, :O))) I guess we can't trust Press TV too much:

 //www.presstv.com/detail.aspx?id=64933

thanks,

Press TV cracks me up!


ramintork

Press TV is a lousy propaganda machine

by ramintork on

And not even a good one! They don't fool anyone other than those who are already fools!

They even contradict themselves, I could have some respect for their shrewdness if they had any but they are just beyond stupid.

Here is what they had on the $18.5BN found in Turkey

//www.presstv.ir/detail.aspx?id=101964&sectionid=351020102

with the title Iranian wants his $18.5BN back and on the same web site we have:-

Turkish minister denying the $18.5BN

 //presstv.com/detail.aspx?id=102063&sectionid=351020102

Followed by Ahmadinejad denying that there was such money in Turkey!

So if the money was not write there why write a story that the Iranian with his lawyer wants his money back. It just shows that this regime is so pothetic that no one could cover their tracks and Press TV as an organization that is suppose to protect their interest is useless when it comes to doing such a task.

 


khaleh mosheh

I dont think this

by khaleh mosheh on

is a new video- remeber seeing this just after the sham elections.

 


mahmoudg

Press TV: the mouth piece of the Mullah's

by mahmoudg on

Until and unless, the Islamic Republic is removed from power, people like him will support terrorism.  Persians have for 1400 years been under this kind of deceit and pressure.


pedro

Never Trust Brits.

by pedro on

Never liked the Brits, never trusted them, Do not like anything about them or the country. Weather sucks, people are cold, and they stole a lot of oil from us building their empire. Been there, in london, hated it.

Typical British greeting.

Good morning SIR. How are you enjoying the Knife I just stabed you with, in the back SIR. Good day to you SIR.

They always, always play both sides. While Press TV is under investigation, at the same time Brown is rubbing someone,s nuts in Iran for contracts and his share of billions from the Islamist regime.