Man beaten by police

Not clear what the victim did (in Tehran?)

13-Nov-2008
Share/Save/Bookmark

Recently by ebi amirhosseiniCommentsDate
Simin Daneshvar: Influential author has died
22
Mar 08, 2012
ایران 1973
5
Oct 18, 2011
حافظ
1
Oct 12, 2011
more from ebi amirhosseini
 
default

Ye pa do pa.

by KouroshS (not verified) on

well, well, well. I did not know there was a human right activists convention going on in town.

You did not read my posting closely, did you?
I did not oppose the right to have a fair trial, all i said was that on the scene of the crime, no one can make a ruling, because no one has all the facts.The police has to follow a certain set of procedures and unfortunately, if they face any form of resistance, they will get down and dirty with you, in iran or usa.

Again, i am not defending beating and injuring in public, But come on, do you want to serve coffee and dougnut and offer a hot shower, to someone who has just committed a crime in your own neighborhood , or would you rather see the cops take him away by any means possible?

Let's see if then you will scream and shout in defense of his or her rights.


default

answer to cime low crime in Saudi Arabia ?high crime in canada?

by hajiagha on

you rung

اقای عصبانی بی منطق چرا در عربستان سعودی خلا کم و یا غیر محسوس و جامعه امنیت دارد و هر کجا ازادی و فرهنگ غربی رفت خلاف و فساد زیاد می شود و میلیارها دلار هزینه برمی دارد شما چند کلاس سواد داری با با یا شاید خلاف  کار ی و حامی خلاف یا وکیل و نون خور از بغل خلاف

and i remmbers every times Iranian governemnt get so hard on punishment crime was go so low , like Arabistan. emarat saudi Arabia , are you can go in saudi Arabia and do easy crime? no , because is hard punishment, why police be so hard on him only?


default

The unfortunate issue is

by daryooush (not verified) on

The unfortunate issue is that there are some that feel the solution to crimes is punishment.


default

ما مردمان احمقی

Dariushagha1 (not verified)


ما مردمان احمقی هستیم... چطور اجازه دادیم ارازل اوباش بر مردم سوار بشوند؟؟؟؟جمهوری اسلامی بطور یقین... وحشی ترین,بیرحمترین و پست ترین رژیم در دنیا باید باشد... به چه حقی نیمه شب جوانهای کشورمان را به کتک میکشند...آنهم دستهای از پشت بسته؟؟؟ تف به این رژیم و کسانی که طرفداری می کنند...یک روزی حساب کف دست آنها خواهد داده شد...


default

Hey kouroshs

by Ye pa Do pa (not verified) on

Have you ever heard of a trial…innocent until proven guilty? How about civility? And so what if cops in Detroit/DC/NY that act in a barbaric manner, an animal is an animal regardless of what country they're in. It's absolutely unnecessary to punish someone with that type of force and brutality, especially if the alleged perpetrator is tied up and defenseless.


default

Nadiash. Really? you wonder

by kouroshs (not verified) on

Nadiash.

Really? you wonder how iranian became this way? let me ask you something, do you wonder how police in detroit or dc or ny , who beat the crap out of basically whomever they want to, became they way they are as well?

Irandoost1901

They may not have any proof right there at the scene whether this guy is any of those criminals you mentioned, But then again neitherdo cops in US and look how they chase and gang up on black and mexicans for various reasons. I agree that the cop was a little too harsh, but i definitely agree with concerned iranian's opinion that some roughness is absolutely necessary to put the real criminals in their places.

Iva

what does police brutality have anything to iran becoming a prosperous nation? and if there really is no law and order in iran, don't you think someone ought to something about it? Don't you see enough brutality in modern countries as well? and given that victims of such brutalities have the right to sue the police, what percentage of the cases do you think really come out successful? The maximum a cop gets is a few weeks of suspension, and the courts do their best to make sure the police wins their cases. That is the bottom line.

Another thing, You are mixing the case of akhoonds and the higher ups with the necessity of having effective and useful law enforcment. Concerned iranian is right cops gotta do what they gotta do. At least the criminals will be forced to think twice before they act.


default

It doesn’t matter where in

by nadiash (not verified) on

It doesn’t matter where in Iran this is or what the guy did. We are watching a brutal act by police officers and this is not acceptable no matter where. Sometimes I wonder how Iranians became this way.


default

"dedicated to do his job"

by Iva (not verified) on

6 people have posted their opinion already … 2 of them condoning the brutal and unlawful act of police while 4 stated their disgust. To me, that approximately equals to 33% of Iranians who have lived in West and are accustomed to rule of law, favor no law where anyone with a gun and power can do as they please, in other words the exact situation that exists in Iran today. That is why, I believe, I will not see a prosperous Iran, not in my lifetime. Number of Iranians who have been brain washed to believe that Iranians need to be hit on the head in order to make them “behave” and accept that humiliation as a part of everyday life is simply too many.

One poster says, [policeman] is dedicated to his job … so, I guess we should send a thank you notes to likes of Lajvardi, the butcher of Evin, and Islamic clerics in Iran for acts such as hanging teenagers in Iran because clerics are truly “dedicated to their jobs”!!!

The other person is simply ignorant, there’s no choice but to ignore him … Basij commanders did such a number on him that even they won’t take him back.


default

Dispeakable

by Irandoost1901 (not verified) on

Hajiagha, I have an idea. Why don't you leave Vancouver and go to a place where the very same officers who are charged as protectors of people act with such disgusting contempt.

This man could be a thief, a rapist, a drug-dealer, or even a murderer. The police should absolutely NOT be so violent in their treatment of him. This is torture at its finest. And, to even do so without due process whereby he is actually found guilty of the crime first by a court of law...

Anyone who can watch this tape and not cringe is made of the same ilk as the Bush and Cheney of the world, with no respect for laws and no regard for human beings.


bahram9821

It is ironic

by bahram9821 on

Ebi thanks, it is ironic that this clip is next to the clip of people chanting for freedom in 1978. In most countries when you see the police you feel safe, but in Iran it is the opposite, when you see a police you wonder what the hell have I done?

default

Let's not judge!

by Concerned Iranian (not verified) on

We have no idea what he did. It does seem that he was some sort of a thief because they found the money on him. In a country that that theft, motorcycle riding robbers, and home invasion is rampant, this cop is doing something about it. I certainly do not agree with the awful method he uses, but he seems dedicated to do his job as a cop. Sometimes thieves will become quite scared when they know something like this is awaiting them.


default

rodney king Iranian style

by MRX1 (not verified) on

Too bad the victim is not in U.S to sue these cops for millions. of course some one needs to tell these cop wanna be what a real cop is and how a real cop should behave, but that's a story for another times...


default

do not break the law if you did Waite for punishment

by hajiagha on

Thank you from Iranian police nice job because in Vancouver canada best city in world with fancy police and high crime now is 7 human feet find on water, and police looking for killer, and be3for this a man was now in jail he responsible for killing over 70 women , every days one crime  murdered in Vancouver, every 30 minute one car stolen, every second one crime in BC canada is best city in world. and why punishment is necessary

you do not liked because you a part of this crime also.

keep clean and do not break law to be safe .


default

This is NOT in tehran.

by KOuroshS (not verified) on

they have such thick accent, a non-tehrani accent.
something about pool shemordan, i heard that uttered by one of the cops right before the end of the tape, and that he caught the guy counting some money...
These Mother fookers are so vicious.