Power to the Greens

The U.S. must empower the Green Movement

Share/Save/Bookmark

Power to the Greens
by Ray Takeyh
19-Feb-2011
 

As Iran's streets erupt with pro-democracy demonstrations, it is all too obvious that the only option the United States has in altering the Islamic Republic's behavior is to support the Green Movement.

The clerical oligarchs have tried hard to prevent the contagion of democracy from afflicting their nation. Despite their maladroit attempt to establish a moral continuity between Iran's 1979 revolution and the recent uprising in Egypt, and their threats of violence and retribution toward those who protest, the mullahs have failed to reclaim their citizens.

It is too facile to suggest that the wave of protests rocking the Middle East was born in Iran, but it is not too simplistic to stress that Iran will not be left behind in the march for freedom.

The Middle East is undergoing one of its most momentous transformations since achieving independence from imperial rule. Although the canard of Islamist takeover has unsettled many pundits and policymakers, the bottom line is that the region has left behind its infatuation with revisionist ideologies. In the streets of Arab capitals we are witnessing the passing of the age of ideology, as neither pan-Arabism, with its promises of modernity, nor Islamism, with its pledges of authenticity, can redeem the region's autocrats. The restive youth and the overburdened middle class can no longer be tempted by faded orthodoxies and false shibboleths that conceal the reality of repression and corruption. In retrospect, the Green Movement that arose after Iran's disputed presidential election in 2009 was not so much a catalyst but a harbinger of this new epoch

As exhilarating as the early stages of the region's political transition may be, democratic upheaval is likely to narrow the conventional options of addressing the threat of Iran's nuclear program. Great powers such as Russia and China that place a premium on stability are unlikely to agree to more economic sanctions. The Arab states preoccupied with renegotiating their national compacts will be reluctant to participate in efforts to isolate the Islamic Republic. And the military option that was always unattractive has now become implausible; it would be rash to employ force against Iran's suspected nuclear installations and radicalize the Arab populace just as forces of moderation and democracy seem ascendant.

All is not lost, however. The only durable solution to Iran's nuclear conundrum was always empowerment of the Green Movement. Tehran's callous leadership, indifferent to the financial penalties of its nuclear truculence, was hardly prone to make cost-benefit assessments and constructively participate in negotiations. Although it has been customary since the disputed presidential election of 2009 for the Washington establishment to pronounce the demise of the Green Movement, the battered Iranian opposition has succeeded in de-legitimizing the theocratic regime and enticing a significant portion of the population to contemplate life beyond the parameters of clerical despotism. Citizens' disenchantment was mirrored by the steady stream of defecting regime loyalists, who have forsaken their revolutionary patrimony. The breakdown of ideological controls in Iran is bound to affect the cohesion and solidarity of its security services. Deprived of popular credibility or a convincing dogma, Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei may not even be able to enforce his rule through fear.

The key challenge for the United States is to find ways to connect with the Green Movement. As important as social media or rhetorical declarations may be, such measures are limited. The model of Eastern Europe is instructive, as the West managed to covertly use a range of institutions, such as the Catholic Church and labor unions, to funnel assistance to dissidents. Several parts of Iranian civil society - labor syndicates, savvy youth, clerical dissidents, liberal protesters and universities - exist in a state of perpetual rebellion; they deserve to be beneficiaries of American advice and assistance. Whether motivated by idealism or a desire to advance practical security concerns, the West must recognize that the only thing standing between the mullahs and the bomb is the Green Movement.

The demise of the Islamic Republic is inevitable. Should the Middle East move toward realizing the aspirations of its citizens, and embrace pluralism and accountability, it is hard to see how a retrogressive clerical tyranny can persist in the region. During the democratic transition, there is still the challenge of tempering Iran's pernicious ambitions, and the mullahs' penchant for terrorism must still be addressed. The chimera of a diplomatic solution should no longer blind the international community to Iran's political vulnerabilities. In the end, the most effective means of disarming the Islamic Republic and ending its reign of terror is to invest in the indomitable Green Movement.

First published in the Wshington Post.

AUTHOR
Ray Takeyh is a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations.

Share/Save/Bookmark

 
Siavash300

U.S has their own agenda, we have ours

by Siavash300 on

Sometimes U.S foreign policy matches to what other countries desire and sometimes it doesn't. They have their own agenda and Iranians have theirs. If they support Iranian uprising, that is fine, if they don't, too bad. Never make such a mistake that U.S is the one who can play major role. Only Iranians make the history of their own. That happened in 1953 and in 1979. Our great nation did it, not foreign establishment.


sumwoman

Council on Foreign Relations!

by sumwoman on

Isn't that a Think Tank group owned and operated by Military Industrial Complex that profits from war, war and more war?

Ray take a hike!


vildemose

I urge everyone to listen

by vildemose on

I urge everyone to listen to this Basiji interview on channel one:

It is mindboggling.

 

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMfDz2H1Qb4

 

via MM


Shutruk

WELL SAID!!!!!

by Shutruk on

 

I agree. Let the Americans empower and support the Green movement in Iran as they have suppported the Greens of Qaddafi and the Greens of  the House of Saud.

The Americans always back tyrants and seditious movements, so backing the greens will only make this true again.


koa

liberty for all

by koa on

Mr.Ray or what ever your name is .USA should not interfere for sake of the iraninan people .we people of iran are capeable of passing all kind of distraction like this evil regim  may through it at us by name of (way of freedem= Kahrobi ; Mossavi )!!!!!!

power to the people of Iran .  long live IRAN in one piece. 


Mardom Mazloom

Anti regime protest (Ottawa) tonight 30 Bahman 1389

by Mardom Mazloom on


Roozbeh_Gilani

اردشیر امیرارجمند، مشاورارشد میرحسین موسوی،

Roozbeh_Gilani



 اردشیر امیرارجمند، مشاورارشد میرحسین موسوی، در گفت و گو با رسا ضمن تکذیب لغو تظاهرات یکشنبه گفت: "راهپیمایی اول اسفند جنبش سبز تحت هر شرایط برگزار می شود و از مردم عزیز می خواهیم به شایعات توجه نکنند." پیش از این کاربران شبکه اجتماعی توئیتر از دریافت پیامک های تلفن همراه مبنی بر لغو راهپیمایی خبر داده بودند.


Everybody Loves Somebody Sometime

Mr. Ray Takeyeh, all America has to do is the bombing raids

by Everybody Loves Somebody ... on

of high value targets in the Islamic Republic:

1) Khamenei's residence,

2) Ahmadinejads' residence,

3) Friday prayers all across Iran,

4) Any pro-regime rallies on the streets,

5) The entire Hozeyeh Elmiyeh Qom,

6) IRGCs locations

7) Basijis locations,

8) All mosques,

9)  IRR Majlis,

10)  Department of interior.

11) others if necessary.

 

Thanks,

ELS


Bavafa

Iranians need to take

by Bavafa on

Iranians need to take charge of their own destiny and feature if they want freedom and a way of life of their own choosing. They need to take risks and I am sure there will be a heavy price to pay to, but this is really the only way they can win and I have no doubt they can win it if they set their mind to it.

With the hopes of a free, independent and prospers Iran for Iranians.

If America really wants to help, they can do so by staying out of it

Mehrdad


vildemose

Iran resident: Protests

by vildemose on

Iran resident: Protests could lead to civil war

 

//edition.cnn.com/2011/WORLD/meast/02/18/iran.protest.qanda/


Anahid Hojjati

Good article, but

by Anahid Hojjati on

IRI might use these kind of articles for its propaganda machine to announce that Iranian democracy movement was created by western powers. But then, perhaps we are beyond how IRI might manipulate anything.


lissnup

Another option

by lissnup on

I see the sentiments in this article regularly.

I distrust this "only option" (how unflattering by the way) because I do not believe it is for the benefit of the green movement. As the article soon reveals, it is all about the nuclear development programme. 

I have mounted a campaign at //speak4iran.org appealing to all governments to implement fiscal and travel restrictions on individuals in the Iranian regime who are responsible for human rights atrocities against prisoners of conscience and political prisoners in Iran. Simple, straightforward, practical measures that would show firm solidarity with the green movement and send a clear message to the regime without impacting on the daily hardships of ordinary Iranian citizens. So there you have another option readily available.

The green movement is not about nuclear development and it never was. 


alimostofi

Ray: US has already given

by alimostofi on

Ray: US has already given them the kiss of death, just like all the other approaches it has made to anyone since 1979.The Greens as we all know are a fake opposition who still want an Islamic Republic.We Iranians do not need anyone's support. We have the spirit of Nowruz that unites us all. Why don't you say that Ray?

Ali Mostofi

//www.alimostofi.com

 


norooz

The U.S. must empower the

by norooz on

The U.S. must empower the Green Movement

AUTHOR
Ray Takeyh is a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations.

Here is a good example of an opposition member who knows nothing about the psyche of hard liners and conservatives.