Why is Roozbeh Gilani Blocked?

Anonymous Observer
by Anonymous Observer
23-Sep-2011
 

Come on JJ.  He was a great contributor.  He had good observations and good understanding and grasp of issues and wrote good blogs.  What did he do to get blocked?  I didn’t see him in a fight with anyone.  You keep getting rid of these good contributors and soon you’ll be left with “fati and hozesh” as we used to say in the old country. 

Come on dude, please give the brother a break and reopen his account. 

Share/Save/Bookmark

Recently by Anonymous ObserverCommentsDate
The 1979 Devolution Was The Perfect Fit For Iranians
72
Nov 24, 2012
Bring Dr. Mohandes & Vildemose Back!!!
31
Nov 08, 2012
Iranian.com, David Duke or "Storm Front?"
66
Oct 12, 2012
more from Anonymous Observer
 
Truthseeker9

VPK

by Truthseeker9 on

All this time you were saying you live in LA and we find you live in Alaska. You dark horse.  ;)


Anahid Hojjati

Dear Masoud, thanks for your comment addressed to me

by Anahid Hojjati on

i hope soon the issue is resolved. it looks like roozbeh has many fans on ic. i don't know what happened that resulted in his blocking. perhaps, admin will write about it later.


Veiled Prophet of Khorasan

Well I

by Veiled Prophet of Khorasan on

 

reviewed the recent exchanges between Roozbeh and Baron. In that light it makes some sense why they would both be booted. 

Regarding "standing up to NIAC". Oh please folks. Half the regular posters on IC have deep vitriol towards NIAC. I do not think you need worry about a shortage of NAIC haters! 


Truthseeker9

Perhaps SamSam and Oon Yaroo have got it

by Truthseeker9 on

Perhaps it is to show "balance" in numbers blocked on both sides of the debate, so that the site appears democratic.

What is also noticeable is when there is longstanding conflict between two persons where one uses own name and the other not, and both break the rules, anonymous ID seems to be the one to get blocked. If someone's identity is known they are not likely to get blocked and get warnings, they seem to be the more "valued" member. Which all seems to make a mockery of Official Rules. I am sorry, but this seems to be the impression of what goes on.


Masoud Kazemzadeh

Dear Anahid

by Masoud Kazemzadeh on

Dear Anahid,

I do not get why in the world the admin would block Roozbeh either. It just does not make any sense. Roozbeh is one of the most thoughtful and decent posters at IC. He did stand up to the supporters of vf regime and NIAC. And they used a lot of nasty insults and personal attacks such as calling him agent of Israel and neo-con and the like. We can see such insults even on this blog.

Roozbeh is one of the rare individuals who was a bridge-builder. He successfully built bridges and friendships with those who differ from him. For example, he built bridges of friendship with pro-democracy posters, independents, and monarchists.

If there is anything we can do to convince the admin to change its sad decision, we should do it. And if there is anything we can do to convince Roozbeh to come back, we should do it.

Roozbeh has been one of those rare and wonderful flowers in our community garden. To eliminate such a wonderful flower while there are so many alaf harz on this site, who on a daily basis making personal attacks and insults against the best posters who fight for democracy, freedom, and human rights is simply sad.

Best,

Masoud


Waders

of kaleh aabie

by Waders on

and the schitzophrenics malloolam o ensaanam arezoost.                    

Veiled Prophet of Khorasan

I am Walrus

by Veiled Prophet of Khorasan on

 

You are all me and I am he and she is and I am the Walrus. "I am he as you are he as you are me and we are all together"

//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Am_the_Walrus


Oon Yaroo

Hey Tabar.....!

by Oon Yaroo on

Wasn’t it a few weeks ago during the holy month of Rama Dama Ding Dong where you were preaching to the rest of us as to how one should be like Ali loving, caring, peaceful, etc. etc. Where does all of these belligerence and thuggish attitude come from you all of a sudden? I thought you were a man of peace or was it the other pis**?

 I do not know RG from a hole in the wall! BUT, I bet he had/has more integrity in his pinky than you and your likes have in your entire existence! Get it!


Raoul1955

Are you Serious?

by Raoul1955 on

I propose that the 'admin' for the site posts a brief explanation for Roozbeh's deletion as a matter of courtesy to everyone.


divaneh

چه عرض کردم؟

divaneh


...


Tabarzin

McCarthyism and bullying

by Tabarzin on

Is the definition of honesty and tremendous insight? Wow, I've heard it all now! Like someone else said, the people with the same bag of bullying and intimidation tactics are the same ones who are speaking out the loudest for an utter thug like RG. Since we are obviously dealing with a closely aligned bloc with a special discusrive interest, go figure...

Some people definitely think and act extremely close to the handles they choose. 


divaneh

Is RG really blocked?

by divaneh on

I can't believe this admin, I have been a way for a few days and look what you've done.

If that is true then it would be a very sad moment when we lose a patriotic Iranian who brought honesty and tremendous insight to the site and debated with a great deal of energy and passion. It's pitty to loose him at the time the site is full of dogs who roam freely and piss on every tree in their way.

I agree with Maziar and others that Admin owes us an explanation as would be the case in any democratic community.

Dear Roozbeh,

I hope you give us the pleasure of your company again.

Faramarz Jaan,

I liked your idea. Can I just add "Ban this tosser" to your list.

 


Simorgh5555

One piece of good news is

by Simorgh5555 on

One piece of good news is that Baron Avak is also blocked. I'm not sure how much him also being thrown out is connected to Roozbeh but Baron did try to bully him.


Disenchanted

Well, I found him confrontational and accusatory at times...

by Disenchanted on

 

          His tone and style was equivalent of "screaming" rather then having a civil conversation. There are few other folks on this site with same style and attitude. I guess they are here lobbying to bring him back.

           I have no idea what was his last sin! Lets put it this way: I have seen 2 or 3 folks on his opposing side being knocked out. Perhaps this levels the field! 


Oon Yaroo

SamSam the 4th, The Shaikhmaster will perform an Estekhareh*

by Oon Yaroo on

and if the result is "good=khoob" then he/she will let RG in!

* Estekhareh should not be confused with profanity! It's a process by which a Shaikh closes the eyes then opens up a random page of Qor'an. On top of the page it either says "khoob" or "bad!" That's how rammals and shaikhs performed fortune telling of the folks!

As I stated in another post the other night, it's like the tossing of a coin, Head = Khoob and Tail=Bad.

 

 


Souri

Roozbeh is really missed, I hope he will be back soon

by Souri on

I don't know what happened to Roozbeh and why he did get block.

Actually it's a while that I can not follow all the thread as I should.

But one thing is sure, Roozbeh is a great asset to the site. He has very good points and is much more civil than many others (especially the troll ones).

Despite some disagreement over some points, I like Roozbeh a lot.

I am sure he will be back soon.


MM

One more vote to bring RG back

by MM on

And, in addition, let us know why?


SamSamIIII

AO jaan, he was blocked so

by SamSamIIII on

 

shotori omarii  herd get a much needed break.  I make a deal with ayatollah Admin that if he reinstate Roozbeh I will gladly leave him & his site alone for 1 year :), come on shaikhmaster, make your wish come true ;, 1 less kiaani nutcase.

 

btw brother AO I can promise you that if the question was put by some sabzollahi or ommatie about some other ommatie abu or shamu our friend JJ would have been on the blog on the double. have seen it time & time again.

 

Cheers pilgrim !!!


G. Rahmanian

RG's Blockade!

by G. Rahmanian on

RG's blockade took place during one of my regular shifts on the site here, so I know why he was blocked. But I'm not going to get into it for the reason I may say something that might open a can of worms. I simply don't like worms! But I can tell you how I became an atheist. It all happened suddenly one day when I was in a cab going back home from college. I just realized I had no use for the "guy up there." I found him unworthy of my thoughts and time. I realized he was such an insensitive, unreasonable, narrow-minded, judgmental and vengeful wretch more in need of my sympathy than my reverence or awe that I couldn't deal with. Why should I want to have anything to do with a pitiful entity like him, I thought to myself. The "conversion" came easy perhaps because I had never been a "true" believer, to begin with.


maziar 58

Admin jaan

by maziar 58 on

for all the civilized reason in the world why still there is no explaination from your side ?

RB and countless others are the BREAD & BUTTER of this site polite,reasonable &...

just because they did not agree with X or Y  shouldn't be a reason to block.

first ammendment been violated IMHO.

Maziar


vildemose

I did not elevate his to

by vildemose on

I did not elevate him to god hood. His perspective were not your run of the mill punditry. I disagreed with many of his opinions but you can't ignore he was a good debator with a sharp analytical mind though not always rigth neither wrong...just a fresh point of view of looking at things.. 

Reform requires the consent of the corrupt


Veiled Prophet of Khorasan

Vildermose Jan

by Veiled Prophet of Khorasan on

 

I have already voted for bringing him back. But I do not share your admiration. He was not that different from many others. Got some things right; some wrong. Why do we have to elevate people to godhood. 


Parham

One more against banning Roozbeh

by Parham on

Count me in.


vildemose

 He stood up to B.s. like

by vildemose on

 He stood up to B.s. like no other on this site. People who are afraid of his razor-sharp intelligence and original perspectives and breadth of knowledge are aboviously glad he is banned.

 "

Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds"

Reform requires the consent of the corrupt


Tabarzin

Keep that lobbyist blocked

by Tabarzin on

That sicko had this long time coming... 


Reality-Bites

One more vote for RG to be unblocked

by Reality-Bites on

Did I agree with RG's every post? No, not necessarily, but he is one of the best posters here, a very decent human being and a true Iranparast to boot. IC will be poorer without him.

Also a note about TL who seems blissfully unaware of the irony of her own posts. While denigrating many people here, which she often does (apparently now many of us are "unhinged" and RG was a "creature", "beyond primitive, psycho-tycally dumb", a "thug" etc etc), she is complaining about RG's behaviour towards others!

You couldn't make it up.


Oon Yaroo

Time after time here posters get blocked NOT becasue they

by Oon Yaroo on

don't want to abide by the rules and regulations but rather because the EDITOR/ADMIN apply arbitrary, inconsistent, ambiguous, and totally random rules that end up in arbitrary, inconsistent, ambiguous, and random deletion/blocking policies.

If the EDITOR/ADMIN of this site designed the traffic lights in your town, there would be a few hundred accidents on a daily basis!

Hey Yo EDITOR/ADMIN here are the rules:

Green means go!

Yellow means slow down!

Red means stop!

State the rules without any ambiguity and then if the members do not abide then you can block them or whatever your heart desires!

Also, EDITOR/ADMIN has/have soft spots for females (i.e,, SK, TL, and the rest of the gang!) It's just the feeling I have! Don't SUE me!

 


Truthseeker9

AO jaan

by Truthseeker9 on

Love the way people make an appearance to rile people and then say "gotta go!"

And THEN say there is no reason I can get on peoples nerves.

Anone got a fly swat???

But anyways, lets not allow the blog to get hijacked, it is about RG and with that in mind, I bid you good night, and hope to see him back soon.  

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=otqcVG-nJGI 


Tiger Lily

GEEE!

by Tiger Lily on

Great. Just great. So many very seriously unhinged people around.

Over 90% of that creature's posts were personal attacks, consistanly harrassing ones, subject to criminal law, and very seriously beyond primitive, psycho-tycally dumb ones. 

Informative yes!:If you want to know what goes on in cesspits of daily hatred of a thug.

How that thing got away with it for so long IS the question!

 

P.S. And no further comment from me to waste my time on that total waste of space.


Veiled Prophet of Khorasan

Do we know

by Veiled Prophet of Khorasan on

 

RG did not get a warning? Maybe he did and we just don't know it.