Physical punishment of children

Abusive swim instructor fired; filmmaker to be "dealt with"

بی بی سی: چند روزیست فیلمی از تنبیه بدنی بچه ها در استخر شیرودی تهران در اینترنت دست به دست می شود. در این فیلم مربی شنا چند کودک را کتک می زند. امروز از مدیرکل ورزشگاه شیرودی نقل شد که این مربی شنا اخراج شده و قرار است با کسی هم که فیلمبرداری کرده برخورد شود. فرزاد کاظم زاده گزارش می دهد:






Instructor punishing kids at Shahid Shrioudi swimming pool:




Original Video - More videos at TinyPic

11-Oct-2010
Share/Save/Bookmark

Recently by Ghormeh SabziCommentsDate
Majid Tavakoli: Prisoner of the day
5
Dec 02, 2012
Nasrin Sotoudeh: Prisoner of the day
2
Dec 01, 2012
Abdollah Momeni: Prisoner of the day
2
Nov 30, 2012
more from Ghormeh Sabzi
 
statira

Not just fire

by statira on

He should be sued by the kid's parents. This psychopat should not be near any kid.


Veiled Prophet of Khorasan

I have not

by Veiled Prophet of Khorasan on

 

really had to physically punish my kids. Not onc time. My kids love me and willingly do the right thing.

I have an American friend who spanks her kid on a regular basis. Her kid in turn is obnoxious and disrespectful of her.  Ironically she is an ex-hippie!

I also know a lot of right wingers who support physical punishment. I was talking to a particularly stupid one. He was talking about how we should bring back "capital punishment" for kids. I asked him if he knew what "capital punishment" means? He said it was beating the kids. I politely reminded him that is meant "executing kids!". The moron had to back off.  The dumber they are; the more they want to beat kids.

This is definitely not to blame on Islam. It is not a Muslim problem rather a much more prevalent one.


iroooni

I have an 8 year old boy that goes to swimming pool

by iroooni on

at theY in the U.S.

it makes me so mad to think that someone would beat my son like that. Thanks god for phone cameras. May be techonology can save the third world and bring it back to this century.


Red Wine

...

by Red Wine on

آن چیزی که ما در ویدِئو دیدیم و در جَرایدِ اِلکترونیکی‌ خواندیم،آنقدر قضیه را داغ ندیدیم که خَلایق اینجور نان در آش کنند و هر کسْ لب و لوچه تَر کند ! این چیز‌ها تا بوده..به این چنین بوده و عجیب است که حال به یاد مُتخصّصین اُفتاده است که باید با آن مبارزه کرد !

مثل همیشه... آفتابه لگن هفت  دست و شام و نِهار هیچ !

اینجور مسائل ریشه یابی‌ فراوان می‌خواهد و وقتِ مَلِک و حُوصله میرزا!

ماشا الله به جانِ شُما !


shushtari

give me 5 min

by shushtari on

with this fat pig.....and after he swallows a couple of gallons of pool water, he'll think twice to hit these poor innocent kids

 

this is exactly what lead to freaks like antarinejad and other psycho fascists.....they got slapped around when they were kids

 

 


Niki Tehranchi

Speedo Yuck!

by Niki Tehranchi on

They should have fired him merely due to that awful speedo!

In all seriousness, I am still scarred by that awful swim instructor I had in Fourth Grade.  She was what we would call today a Butch but in those days merely thought of her as a very homely, scary looking woman.  She consistently picked on me because I was more scared than the other kids of being in the water.  What the hell kind of teacher thinks it is a good idea to scare you even more as a way to get you to embrace swimming?  I still remember when she actually lifted her arm and made as if to strike me across the face and her fellow teacher actually had to restrain her.  By the way, this happened in France in the mid-80s.

In her book Funny in Farsi, Firoozeh Dumas recalls her own awful experience with swimming when her aunt, an educated doctor respected by her whole family, decided the best way to overcome her fear of water was to simply throw her in the middle of the pool and let her sink to the bottom before begrudgingly rescuing her from drowning.

Some adults should NEVER EVER be around children, much less teach them.


comrade

Deep end!

by comrade on

I don't care about BBC® or You Tube®, I'm just wondering how our own JJ feels after being at least partially responsible for the instructor's loss of job  and kids receiving the wrong message!

Never increase, beyond what is necessary, the number of entities required to explain anything.

 


choghok

Funny, punish the camera man :-)

by choghok on

One big problem for us iranians is feel shame and guilt that makes us impossible to be transparent, even a city swimmingpool that has to serve its customers wants to punish them since they broadcast clips from it.

And another thing to all those people that want to relate all our problems to an outsider, grow up. After 1400 yrs accept the fact and move on or you will be miserable all your life. And beside there are lots of parents beating their children in christian countries. 11 countries in EU allow this for example. Is it also because of Islam? 


azadi5

Perfect background music

by azadi5 on

Nice choice. They picked Pink Floyd's Another Brick In The Wall for the BBC report. Well thought.


Milan

Complacency: Akh Tof!

by Milan on

Equally at fault are those grown men, one of whom even glances toward the direction of the echo; unmoved, he goes about his business like a cow.


opinionpost

Why Punish?

by opinionpost on

I understand your concern on discipline, however...why would you punish in a Swimming pool? It is supposed to be fun, caring, fatherly love environment? Kids grow in soul and happiness flows, why would you be a cup there? Seriously!

When kids are happy and together, they mostly take orders, listen to their teacher... there is not crazy, outlaw crawling in the water....

Unless, some one like that psycho safe gaurd sees it that way... 

Funny, Pool's management are looking for the person who taped it.. TYPICAL IRI approach.... lets hide it.... 


asadabad

the science of discipline

by asadabad on

somone needs to invent a humane but effective way of punishing children for misbehaving...that should be a new Nobel Prize category.


opinionpost

Have no choice

by opinionpost on

But Adore your comment....


mahmoudg

Islammmmmmmmmmmmm

by mahmoudg on

way to go Mohamad and your filthy cult.