Diplomacy, regime change, or war?

Results of national survey of Iranian Americans

Share/Save/Bookmark

Diplomacy, regime change, or war?
by PAAIA
11-Dec-2011
 

The Public Affairs Alliance of Iranian Americans (PAAIA) has released the findings of its third national public opinion survey of Iranian Americans. The 2011 survey follows similar surveys commissioned by PAAIA in 2008 and 2009. The surveys are an integral component of better understanding the Iranian American community and having its voice heard through the availability of on-going accurate scientific data.

PAAIA 2011 Survey Highlights

In October of 2011, PAAIA commissioned Zogby Research Services (formally known as Zogby International) to conduct a public opinion survey of Iranian Americans to gather accurate attitudinal and demographic information about the Iranian American community. The results of the 2011 PAAIA survey indicate that over the past three years, the importance of ethnic heritage to Iranian Americans remains unchanged, with eighty-three percent (83%) believing that their heritage is either very important or somewhat important to them. Iranian Americans continue to retain close ties to family and friends in Iran, although percentages of respondents who say they have family in Iran has dropped off somewhat. Still six in ten Iranian Americans indicate that they communicate with their family and friends in Iran at least several times a month.

Most Iranian Americans (43%) believe that internal developments in Iran and the state of U.S.-Iran relations are at the core of their issues as Iranian Americans. These issues correlate and are at the heart of domestic issues involving Iranian Americans in the United States (e.g., civil rights, discrimination, etc.).

Iranian Americans want the Iranian regime to change. For the above mentioned self-interested reason, two-thirds of Iranian Americans believe that Iran should be a secular democracy. In contrast, only six percent (6%) believe that any form of an “Islamic Republic” would work well in Iran. The survey indicates that from among a list of six issues relating to U.S.-Iran relations, by far the greatest number of Iranian Americans (63%) cite the promotion of human rights and democracy as the most important, followed by thirty percent (30%) who cite the promotion of regime change.

However, though Iranian Americans want to see a democratic Iran that respects human rights, they differ on how the foregoing aspirations can be achieved. Thirty eight percent (38%) believe that diplomatic negotiations or establishing diplomatic relations (each received 19%) are the best foreign policy approaches vis-à-vis Iran that would also be in the best interests of the United States. In contrast, thirty-two percent (32%) of Iranian Americans believe that the promotion of regime change would be in the best interest of the United States. Only three percent (3%) of Iranian Americans favor a military option against Iran.

A large majority of seventy-three percent (73%) of Iranian Americans strongly support or somewhat support the establishment of a U.S. interest section in Iran that would provide consular services and issue U.S. visas. This is in keeping with the 2008 survey results, in relation to the fact that sixty-one percent (61%) of Iranian Americans have traveled to Iran at least once since moving to the United States, and the continued close ties they maintain with family and friends living in Iran.

A significant portion (44%) of Iranian Americans cite restrictions on transferring money between Iran and the U.S as having a somewhat burdensome or a very burdensome impact on their ability to support their families. A similar percentage, forty-seven percent (47%), view U.S. sanctions as not very burdensome or not at all burdensome on them or their family. This, however, does not discount the difficulties that the former group encounters on a daily basis as a result of the sanctions.

A majority (56%) of Iranian Americans now disapprove of President Obama’s handling of relations with Iran, while thirty-two percent (32%) approve of how the President addresses this issue. These numbers have flipped since 2009 when a majority of Iranian Americans viewed President Obama’s handling of relations with Iran favorably. Although their favorable attitude towards the Obama Administration’s policy towards Iran has declined, fifty-five percent (55%) of Iranian Americans indicate that they would vote for President Obama if the 2012 election were held today.

When asked if they would support or oppose the delisting of the Mujahadeen-e Khalq (MEK) from the State Department’s list of foreign Terrorist Organizations, a plurality of Iranian Americans (45%) cite that they are somewhat opposed or strongly opposed, while twenty-two percent (22%) indicate that they strongly support or somewhat support, and one-third were unsure.

Summary of Results

The 2011 survey results can be viewed from a diversity of viewpoints. Clearly, Iranian Americans continue to regard their culture and heritage as an important component of their day to day life and their overall identity within the United States. Their desire and ability to maintain close contact with their families and friends in Iran is a clear testament to this strong affinity. Though they continue to be active and productive participants in the social and civic life within the United States, Iranian Americans’ desire for a different regime in Iran, one that respects human rights and democracy, is clearly manifested in the survey. Although the predominant majority of Iranian Americans are strongly opposed to any military action against Iran, Iranian Americans differ in their views between diplomacy and regime change as the best course of action for the U.S. to take towards Iran. While support for both tightening or removing economic sanctions against Iran as policy options receive little support, a significant number of Iranian Americans find the restrictions imposed by the sanctions as burdensome on them and their families.

Please click here for the complete report

 

PAAIA's surveys are conducted by Zogby Research Service (formally known as Zogby International), a pre-eminent polling firm, based on successful telephone interviews in English with representative sample of respondents. Zogby Research Service employs sampling strategies in which selection probabilities are proportional to population size within area codes and exchanges. The margin of error for the results of the 2011 survey are +/- 5 percentage points, which is an acceptable margin of error for a survey of this type.

Share/Save/Bookmark

more from PAAIA
 
Darius Kadivar

AmirParviz Jan I suppose you meant the IRANICAN Syndrome ;0)

by Darius Kadivar on

SATIRE: The Burqa Republic of Our IRANICAN Dreams ;0)

But it is said that with some deeper understanding of existing  democratic systems, global knowledge and an openminded discourse it may be curable ...  

Young Constitutionalist Explains why he Favors Monarchies over Republics 

;0)) 

 

PS: VPK jan don't take it personally we are teasing you my friend  ;0)


amirparvizforsecularmonarchy

Darius K, VPK's Mind is Filtering Again

by amirparvizforsecularmonarchy on

Thats what happens when one looks at the world through eyes that are more American than American eyes, Stockholm Syndrome is common among Iranians living and working in the USA.  You have Iran, it's culture, its people, its traditions, it's society and thought processes, then you have the effects of Stockholm Syndrome.

 


Darius Kadivar

VPK Jan Where did you read Secular 'Republic' ?

by Darius Kadivar on

I just saw" Secular Democracy": 

 

Iranian Americans want the Iranian regime to change. For the above mentioned self-interested reason, two-thirds of Iranian Americans believe that Iran should be a secular democracy. In contrast, only six percent (6%) believe that any form of an “Islamic Republic” would work well in Iran. The survey indicates that from among a list of six issues relating to U.S.-Iran relations, by far the greatest number of Iranian Americans (63%) cite the promotion of human rights and democracy as the most important, followed by thirty percent (30%) who cite the promotion of regime change.

 

As for Opinion Polls Well ...

How to Get the results you want:

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=3gMcZic1d4U

If you can't see the video here is the text:

//www.imdb.com/title/tt0086831/quotes

;0))


 


Veiled Prophet of Khorasan

Very mixed up

by Veiled Prophet of Khorasan on

 

This is really interesting as it indicates probably as much about the poll. Here are some very stark contradictions:

  • 2/3 say they want a Secular Republic
  • 6 %want an Islamic Republic.
  • 1/3 say they want regime change.

How could you have a Secular Republic without a regime changes? I mean even a totally non violent one. It still requires a regime change to get rid of the Islamic Republic. But only 6 % want an Islamic Republic leaving27.4 which is unaccounted for!! Do they have no opinion at all?

Regarding war that is all how it is stated.

If you ask: Do you want America to bomb Iran I bet 97% or more including me say no. If you say "If Iranians rise up as in Libya should America help protect them from IRGC many more say "yes".

If you say do you want regime change like in Iraq or Afghanistan? People say "are you nuts?"! But if you state it differently like "Would you want Iran to have a regime like in France or Germany?" probably 90% will say absolutely!

I have not examined the report but plan to do that. Meanwhile the short seems to be: people want a Secular Democracy without war. They new regime without regime change :-) I would love to have my cake and eat it too. Good luck dreaming.


alimostofi

Cultural values....... What

by alimostofi on

Cultural values.......

What happened to cultural values? I am sure that most people would put culture above human rights. That would have been a good question. But I have heard that America has a strange effect on immigrants, wth strong historical cultural heritages, that are not religious.

Ali Mostofi

//twitter.com/alimostofi

 


Roozbeh_Gilani

on 3% and a historical precedence

by Roozbeh_Gilani on

Benitto Mussolini's picture was a permanent fixture in the overwhelmingly anti war (99% of italian americans were against US invasion of Italy), until the day US forces landed on sicily, using some of the "overwhelmingly anti-war" italian american soldiers. I hear, that upon news of Mussolini's capture and execution  by Italian communist partisans, with publication of picture of dead fascist dictator hanging upside down next to his sweetheart, in a Rome square full of cheering italian-italians, some of the empty spaces left by benitto's pictures in Little Italys all over US were filled with pictures of Stalin!

Disclaimer: I am 100% anti war. I believe that khamenei and ahmadinezhad's final capture and trial and what follows next, belongs to us, the Iranians. Kind of our "undeniable right" if you get my drift...

"Personal business must yield to collective interest."


default

What a shame our leaders are amongst the 3%

by ahosseini on

 The leader of our Newsecularism is amongst the 3%.

With the help of American troop, he can lead the 3% to take part in some kind of Guerilla warfare to free Iran.

And our philosopher friend can teach them dialectic of materialism so he can turn the revolutionary movement into mass popular uprising.

May god bless our leaders and America

Believe in a democracy that leaders and representatives are controlled by members at all times.


Bavafa

Of the 3% ....

by Bavafa on

Are any of them that are not an active member of IC?

'Hambastegi' is the main key to victory 

Mehrdad


Tavana

Trolololo!!

by Tavana on

 

Of any news/stats/etc. in relation with 'Iranians Americans,' 'NIAC,' 'PAAIA,' play the below as their validities/seriousness:

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=woySeSNBL3o&feature...

 


پندارنیک

Of stats...

by پندارنیک on

Void of any shape and form of sarcasm, this is the question that I have: What's the percentage of Iranians in the US, (please forgive me that I don't go with the fabricated and farce term of Iranian-American), or even better, what's the percentage of Iranians living abroad who flew or were flown to our beloved motherland for the sole purpose of objection to the result of the presidential election and fled back as soon as they realized the game was rated 18+........?

I want only the writer of the blog to reply to my comment, IF he or she wishes.


Jahanshah Javid

Regime change >>> democracy

by Jahanshah Javid on

What I found most interesting (I was not surprised at all by the miniscule pro-war percentage) is that a third want regime change (read: want democracy). And be sure that the majority of the pro-diplomacy third are sick of the Islamic Republic too.

Those who focus their efforts primarily on preventing war and crippling sanctions must realize that being soft on the Islamic Republic, or not being pro-active in promoting democracy is not going to gain them popularity.


afshin

.

by afshin on

.


Jahanshah Javid

Only 3% for war? Moosh bokhoradeshoon :)

by Jahanshah Javid on

Iranian Americans are the largest community of expat Iranians. Their views matter, and when the survey is done professionally like this, it counts. Thank you PAAIA!