Khomeini: Islam & Democracy

1979 speech against those who want Iran to be a republic, not an Islamic republic

09-Jul-2011
Share/Save/Bookmark

Recently by mehrdadmCommentsDate
Omid Djalili: The Baha'i Faith in Words and Images
11
Dec 05, 2012
Dimmed Lanterns
1
Dec 05, 2012
Iranian TV shows off 'captured US ScanEagle drone'
5
Dec 04, 2012
more from mehrdadm
 
salman farsi

Islam (not Velayat Faqih) is compatible with democracy

by salman farsi on

 

One of the most delicate points missed by the likes of VPK and all those who berate Islam is the principle of Shura (consultation) which is inherent in Islam and more so in Shi'a Islam. Khomeini breached this fundamental principle by adhereing to the made up principle devised by Naraqi (in 19th century) and a golden opportunity to show the world that Islamic democracy can flourish was lost.

 For an Islamic democracy


Roozbeh_Gilani

Dear Amir:

by Roozbeh_Gilani on

A realtive of mine (RIP), who spent time at various SAVAK jails whilst a student, and later same jails under Islamic regime, told me that SAVAK actually encouraged and even funded the islamist prisoners to fight against the left and secular prisoners. He actually once himself had a  fight with the chief illiterate islamist thug, Lajvardi at SAVAK jail,  for which he paid a high price later after the islamist regime took over.

Basically Amir, SAVAK used and encouraged Islamism as a tool against the perceived  threat of soviet/cuban/chinese style of communism in Iran. This is precisely why the islamists were so organised, ready and could take advantage of the power vaccume created during 1978-79. The reason Khomeini was not killed, and sent to a nice comfortable house in Baghdad and later Paris before his flight back (business class of course!!) to Iran is just that.

If any consolation for us, other people in the region, including afghanistan and pakistan suffered from the same master startegy of islamists vs communists.  

"Personal business must yield to collective interest."


AMIR1973

The Shah's biggest crime

by AMIR1973 on

Was listening to the advice of Hassan Pakravan and Ayat. Shariatmadari and exiling this animal rather than killing him. When this animal returned to Iran in 1979 he had Pakravan executed and Shariatmadari (the most senior Ayat. in Shia Islam and the man who had helped spare Khomeini's life by making him a Grand Ayat.) severely humiliated and likely tortured as well. Think of how many countless lives could have been spared if the Shah had killed this Islamist thug before he had a chance to inflict his damage on Iran and the world.


عموجان

What a dark clip, and I don’t mean light, exposure.

by عموجان on


Look like Death is giving his last warring before the killing starts and his assassin are waiting for his order to attack.

I hope where ever he is now with his bosses Mohammad, Ali and rest of them are enjoying raping their 7 virgins and drinking blood of their victims they killed. 


vildemose

Khebe, this was a 'man' that

by vildemose on

Khebe, this was a 'man' that sanctioned raping of virgins

by Hooshang Tarreh-Gol on Sat Jul 09, 2011 11:14 PM PDT

the night before their execution. Please elaborate and enlighten all of us as to what part of this you see as 'great?'

The problems remains fascist leaders and followers like Ayat Shaytan Khomeini and you.

spot on. Khebedin=NP


Benyamin

The biggest traitor was Khomeini himself!

by Benyamin on

History will judge him as one person that damaged the cause of revolution even for islamists!


amirparvizforsecularmonarchy

The Longer Islam Rules Over Iranians In Govt

by amirparvizforsecularmonarchy on

The More Damage will be done to Islam.

We Now have 4 main groups in Iran.

1) Those who were never practicing Muslim.

2) Those who out of betrayal, shame, disgust and humiliation have left islam for good.

3) Those who are muslims but don't support IRI or Islam in Government.

4) Those who are muslim and love IRI all the way.

The longer Islam stays in Iran, the more people will leave 3 and join 2.

The less people in 3 join 1 and 2 to fight against people 4 and are silent regarding goodness, truth and human dignity, the sooner people 3 will be digraced and disowned by people in groups 1 and 2.  The more people 3 sit on the fence the more their religion will be tarnished beyond repair.

Before the French revolution, mostly catholic priests ruled France, when it finally occured, there were over a million executions of people in group 3 and 4. 

The time has long past for Islam to leave govt in Iran. 

Muslims... Go nice and quietly... or the people of Iran will sooner or later not be able to restrain their anger and they will bury anyone that has anything to do with 4 or people that were muslim but quietly sat by and did not stop the bloodshed and crimes of IRI against fellow Iranians.

 

 

 


Veiled Prophet of Khorasan

Hooshang

by Veiled Prophet of Khorasan on

 

It all depends on how you define the word "Great". 

Khomeini was a "Great" **hole and "Great" as was Ghanighiz Khan. He did great evil and harm to people. There is no question he had great negative impact on Iran. He also did great disservice to humanity. One great thing he did was to open our eyes to Islam. He showed us what Islam really is. That service I thank him for :-) He proved Shariati and his nonsense about political Islam was wrong.

You see there is a silver lining to it. Once Iran recovers from this period we will have learned a lesson. A very pricey lesson but one we needed. No more falling for Melli-Mazhabi. Therefore we have a lot to thank him for as he burns in ***.


Veiled Prophet of Khorasan

No

by Veiled Prophet of Khorasan on

 

Islam is not compatible with democracy as we know. It is compatible with a pseudo democracy where "Alama" or a gang of clerics decide. That is not democracy in its normal form.

Islam also marginalizes non Muslims into three gorups:

  • Muslims: the men get full rights; women do not.
  • Ahle Ketab - they get partial rights but must be subservient.
  • Kaffir - they get no rights not even to life. They must become Muslim or die.

If you call that democracy then sure. But I don't call that democracy.


default

Khebe, this was a 'man' that sanctioned raping of virgins

by Hooshang Tarreh-Gol on

the night before their execution. Please elaborate and enlighten all of us as to what part of this you see as 'great?'

The problems remains fascist leaders and followers like Ayat Shaytan Khomeini and you.


Khebedin

He was a great man. Th

by Khebedin on

He was a great man. Th eproblem is ours, not his. Wake up Iranians.


Roozbeh_Gilani

"golden age"

by Roozbeh_Gilani on

During an interview, recently I heared Mr Mousavi's spokesman  eluding that his (Mousavi's) reference to "golden age" was the time when khomeini was in France  promissing French republican style of democracy with a hint of islam to the people of Iran fed up with shah and his SAVAK.

Just an excuse? Yet another false promise? you be the judge of that. 

"Personal business must yield to collective interest."


amirparvizforsecularmonarchy

Maha Kher Kha Heh Iran Hastim

by amirparvizforsecularmonarchy on

Jooneh Amat.

Agar in Islam Kher eh Iran hast,

Vay be haleh doshmanha,

Islam sabet dareh mikoneh ke khaentarin, dozd tarin, be shakhsiyat tarin gesmateh tamameh tarikheh iran hast.

Be in dalil, ma majboorim be harfeh mardom keh din az deleshoon kandeh shodeh goosh bedin va in sarataneh masabeh islamro be khedmatesh beresim. 

Bozorg tarin khaenaeh iran basiji ha, mollah-ha, va khomeini parastah hastan, 

hookomatikeh roo khoon sakhteh shodeh davam khayand nadasht. 

har roozi keh melat islamro tajrobeh mikonand, islam bishtar az bain mireh dar iran.  belekhareh saratoon ro melateh iran miboreh. vastin va bebinin.

 


Jahanshah Javid

Golden Age :)

by Jahanshah Javid on

besides his clear opposition to democracy from the earliest days, notice he talks about "enheraaf" -- a word being thrown around by pro-Khamenei camp these days to discredit Ahmadinejad and his friends. if the greens don't break completely with this guy and the "golden age"... they'll be history too.